An employee posts something inflammatory, discriminatory, or embarrassing on their personal social media account. You find out about it. What do you do?
This is a question more small businesses are navigating — and the answer is more complicated than most employers expect. The legal framework is still evolving, the risks run in both directions, and the right response depends heavily on what was posted, where, and whether it has any connection to the workplace.
At-will employment does not mean you can discipline someone for any social media post. Several legal protections intersect here: the National Labor Relations Act protects employees' rights to discuss working conditions — including on social media — even in non-union workplaces. Some state laws extend broader free speech protections to private-sector employees. And discipline decisions that appear to target protected characteristics (race, religion, national origin, etc.) create discrimination exposure even when the stated reason is a social media post.
Context matters enormously. A post that disparages the company's management, even in harsh terms, may be protected concerted activity. A post containing explicit harassment of a coworker is a different situation. A post reflecting the personal political views of the employee may be protected depending on the state. An employee who identifies themselves as working for your company and posts content that violates your policies is yet another situation.
A social media policy should make clear what it does and does not cover: the policy applies to posts where the employee identifies themselves as working for the company, or where the posts have a direct and demonstrable impact on the workplace or the company's reputation. The policy should not attempt to prohibit all discussion of the company or working conditions — that likely violates the NLRA.
Before you discipline an employee for a social media post, consult an employment attorney — especially if the post touches on working conditions, wages, or workplace treatment. The risk of disciplining protected activity is significant enough to warrant the one-hour consultation cost before taking action.
Social media misconduct is one of those HR situations where the instinctive response is often the legally risky one. Slow down, document what you observed, and get guidance before acting.
ValuedHR helps small and growing businesses build the HR systems they need without the overhead of a full-time hire.
Let's Talk