Large companies have dominated the headlines on return-to-office mandates. But smaller businesses are navigating the same question — and often with less flexibility, less legal resources, and higher stakes for each individual employment relationship.
In most at-will states, employers can require employees to return to an office. But there are important exceptions: employees with disability-related accommodations for remote work may be entitled to continue it under the ADA. Employees in states with expanded family care laws may have claims if a return-to-office mandate disproportionately affects their ability to comply. And if remote work was written into an employment contract or offer letter, changing it without consent creates a breach of contract exposure.
Requiring employees who were hired as remote workers to report to an office is one of the fastest paths to voluntary turnover. Research from 2025 consistently shows that remote work flexibility ranks among the top three factors in employment decisions — particularly for high performers who have the most options.
The most successful return-to-office transitions start with a clear "why" — a genuine business reason for in-person collaboration, not a generalized preference for visibility. They involve employees in the design, allow transition time, and accommodate individual circumstances rather than applying a one-size policy across all roles and teams.
The question is not whether you can require people to come back. It is whether it is the right decision for your business, your team, and the talent market you are operating in. Those are different questions.
ValuedHR helps small and growing businesses build the HR systems they need without the overhead of a full-time hire.
Let's Talk